Site url: https://www.momentum.co.za/momentum/personal/investments/invest/offshore-investing/global-matters/weekly-digest/tisataafl
Pagecontext: org.apache.jasper.runtime.PageContextImpl@79d01d05
NameValue
breadcrumb.start.level4
ibm.portal.instantiation.page.include.descendantsfalse
param.sharing.scope.{http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/prod/datatype/content}ibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
param.sharing.scope.{http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/prod/datatype/content/resource-collections}ibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
param.sharing.scope.{http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/prod/websphere/portal/v8.0/portal-contextual-portal}ibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
wcm.template.oidZ6_48GC1K80O0FH90QS83FHN530K6
flush.cache?01102021
breadcrumb.enabledtrue
param.sharing.scope.{http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/prod/websphere/portal/publicparams}path-infoibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
param.template.pageZ6_48GC1K80O0FH90QS83FHN530K6
page.keywordsOffshore investing
hide.from.menutrue
param.sharing.scope.{http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/prod/websphere/portal/v7.0/portal-contextual-portal}ibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
hide.childrentrue
breadcrumb.stop.level4
dynamic.sitemapfalse
param.sharing.scope.{http://ibm.connections.com/portlet}ibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
page.robotsall
label.namepersonal
sitecontext:personal
ibm.template.oidZ6_48GC1K80O0FH90QS83FHN530K6
menu.dividertrue
menu



Andrew Hardy, CFA | 29 June 2020

Tisataafl

Share this article

Not that there aren’t enough acronyms flying around the investment world already, but today I will reference a lesser known one – only to debunk it. TANSTAAFL: “there ain’t no such thing as a free lunch”. The etymology is uncertain, but the principle is intuitive; there aren’t many things in life that come for free without some form of cost, be it direct or indirect, explicit or implicit. However, there is one (and only one) in finance – diversification. Most famously highlighted by Harry Markowitz, Nobel Laureate and pioneer of investment theory, this has underpinned several decades of progress towards building more sophisticated, more resilient approaches to portfolio management. Although well diversified portfolios have arguably disappointed versus expectations this year, we believe they are more relevant than ever in today’s market environment and should continue to be the strategy of choice for long term investors.

First, some caveats. True diversification requires careful research, analysis and consideration. There is no ‘free lunch’ available from just assembling a portfolio that is diversified only by names – a list of different companies or funds that have similar return drivers or characteristics. Also, although defensive assets are often regarded as the best diversifiers for a portfolio, they usually reduce long term return potential. Instead, the ‘free lunch’ argument is strongest when one considers investments with similar return prospects but different drivers and characteristics. This underpins the long-term case for a multi-asset investment approach; combining asset classes and individual securities that are less than perfectly correlated, resulting in portfolio volatility that is lower than the sum of the parts.

However, through the crisis period in February and March, well diversified strategies lagged some that were more narrowly invested. High growth stocks and government bonds mostly held up well, but most other asset classes were hit much harder and cross asset correlations rose to their highest levels in over 20 years. Volatility spiked to over 5x the level of the prior five years in the case of corporate bonds and listed real estate, while even global government bonds collapsed 9% over a 10-day period in March. Some of these moves were consistent with past crises, but the extent of the underperformance of areas such as real estate and infrastructure and the sell-off in corporate bonds were very unusual.

This talks to why well diversified strategies did not provide as much downside protection as may have been expected but should not be viewed as undermining the long-term case for portfolio diversification.

Instead, such an extreme and unexpected scenario should remind us of the fundamental reason for seeking diversification. In what is a similarly possible and extreme theoretical scenario of a cyber virus, the market moves may have been turned on their head with investments in the physical world holding up instead of those in the digital world. The so called ‘FANGS’ (comprising Amazon, Netflix and the like) may be great businesses and ones that we all enjoy the benefits of, but with a universe of thousands of securities to choose from, should an investor in US equities really have nearly a quarter of their money in those few companies like passively managed strategies have?

There’s a natural tendency to concentrate portfolios into yesterday’s winners, either through a passive approach that chases winners by design or as the path of least resistance. Some of the greatest value that professional investment managers can add is through countering the behavioural biases that so often undermine investor returns. Periods of dislocation create high levels of mispricing and present opportunities to multi-asset investors like us and the specialist managers we allocate to. As markets have rebounded since late March many multi-asset strategies have exceeded expectations, particularly those which were invested for the long term and didn’t cut risk at that point of most pain. We believe this outperformance can continue as many parts of markets – including sub-investment grade bonds, real estate securities and value stocks – remain at depressed levels and are paying investors handsomely as providers of capital whilst they wait for a recovery. Many offer yields in the mid to high single digits, compared to near zero for most high growth stocks and government bonds.

Perhaps the coronavirus will threaten portfolios once again, but risks abound and it’s the ones that catch investors by surprise that we should worry about most. There are many known unknowns that could come into greater focus, such as around the US election or a resurgence in trade wars, as well as many unknown unknowns. As was well put by another Nobel Laureate, Neils Bohr: “prediction is very difficult, especially if it's about the future!”. At a time when explicit portfolio insurance - in the form of traditional defensive assets or options strategies - is relatively expensive, genuine diversification should be ever more appealing.

Share this article

In case you missed it

22 JUNE 2020

The Great Disconnect?

Stephen Nguyen, CFA

With most countries globally facing what could be the worst economic collapse in the post-war era, it is surprising to see markets and most risk assets continue their remarkable rebound. Is this a true reflection of what is going on in the underlying economy or is there a big disconnect?

15 JUNE 2020

Looking forward

Jackson Franks

For most businesses, rent is one of the highest cost items on their P&L statement. With the successful transition of employees working from home, why would businesses continue to pay for space?



08 June 2020

Playing the odds

Robert White, CFA

Making correct investment decisions is inherently more complex and consequential than predicting the outcome of a sporting fixture, and so it is important that investors are well informed and aware of the potential for emotional biases to impact decision making.

We and our selected partners use cookies to enhance and personalise your experience on our website.Please see our cookie policy for more information.

To enhance your user experience on our site, read the website terms and conditions about our supported browsers.

Your browser's cookies are disabled. Enable cookies to ensure our website functions correctly. View our Privacy Notice.

Tell us more!
We're always looking for ways to improve your online experience. Please take a moment to complete the
2-minute questionnaire.