Site url:
Pagecontext: org.apache.jasper.runtime.PageContextImpl@7755503a
page.keywordsInvestments, Savings, Savings plan, Saving for retirement, Discretionary fund management, Investment portfolio
A black and white head and shoulder picture of the author of the internations diversification article, Greg Davies, in a black suit jacket and white shirt.


In love with the familiar

The right and wrong ways to deal with our
preference for the known

Share this article

Go global for a free lunch

A core investing lesson is that diversification is a good thing, perhaps even a financial free lunch. As a guide to someone having a basic grasp of sensible investment essentials, it’s right up there with knowing that investing is a long-term pursuit and that past performance is no guarantee of future performance.

While short-term crashes can correlate across countries, over the long run, markets that live apart, die apart. 1 International diversification thus protects long-term investors from the risk of a country going missing for a decade or two - especially useful if that same country is also paying your wages.

Yet across the world, both amateurs and professionals make a conscious effort to ignore international diversification in portfolio construction, often to a considerable degree.

The Sydney Opera House, shot from below, to show its sharp, granite tiled roofs against a litght blue sky.

International diversification thus protects long-term investors from the risk of a country going missing for a decade or two.

The answer – as ever where the technically ‘correct’ deviates from the practically observed – is that people buy stories, not investments. Without a supporting framework of fairytale-esque familiarity, diversification leads to discomfort. Viewed from another angle, familiarity breeds unjustifiable comfort: investors have an innate, and costly, preference for concentrated portfolios of nice narratives, rather than diversified portfolios of good investments.

Investors pick not the answer that keeps the textbook happy, but the one that keeps themselves happy. That delivers not an impersonal theoretically optimal risk-adjusted return, but a personal, and often costly, anxiety adjusted return: they give up financial efficiency for emotional comfort. If diversification causes distress, it ceases to be such an obviously smart idea. A certain amount of home bias can be useful in buying emotional comfort at relatively low cost, but most investors veer too much to the familiar, and pay too much as a result.

Nothing to fear

From an abstract fear of the unknown, to peer-group regret avoidance, to simple, but not necessarily pure, xenophobia, investors may derive comfort from the devils they know in several ways.

While changes to investments could be called for – of all the deviations from the ‘optimal’ portfolio, a limited amount of home bias is one of the better ones – changes to the decision - making processes and communications that surround the investments are a more cost-effective means to the same ends. Even when deliberate home bias is a cost-effective source of emotional comfort, it’s even more so when accompanied by narratives that draw investor attention to the more naturally familiar components of a portfolio. Because humans neglect scale in narratives, a story emphasising a holding making up, say, 5% of a portfolio may provide comfort with 100% of it.

Other examples include: encouraging phasing for acclimatising to foreign assets; agreeing to govern decisions by pre-set rules, thus diminishing the emotional pull of in-the-moment prejudices; bundling familiar and unfamiliar assets together; and focusing reports on high - level stories rather than individual component performances.

Knowing which solutions to adopt in which circumstances means knowing the investor they’re being adopted by. Deviations are unnecessary if the investor doesn’t care in the first place, and different sources of discomfort call for different remedies. The key to this is profiling, which is why Familiarity Preference is one element of Oxford Risk’s Financial Personality Assessment.

A high preference for familiar investments can tailor not only the adviser-client relationship, but also an investor’s education, for example, specific training to become less attached to home-market benchmarks.

The London Eye

Knowing which solutions to adopt in which circumstances means knowing the investor they’re being adopted by.

Risk free

While the optimal ratio of home to overseas assets is unclear, skewing a portfolio on the grounds of geographic familiarity is unsupported... economically, at least.

Investors are humans, and as such are, in the words of J.G. Ballard, ‘Desperate for the new, but disappointed with anything but the familiar’. When moving into the new world of investments, it’s important not to confuse familiarity with safety (it can be the reverse!) nor to blindly adopt unnecessarily expensive solutions to problems that lie more with perceptions than portfolios.

1 Asness, C., (2010). International Diversification Works (Eventually). Financial Analysts Journal, Volume 67

Share this article

About the author

Greg B Davies, PhD

Greg is a specialist in applied behavioural finance, decision science, impact investing, and financial wellbeing.

He founded the banking world’s first behavioural finance team at Barclays in 2006, which he led for a decade.

In 2017 he joined Oxford Risk to lead the development of behavioural decision support software to help people make the best possible financial decisions.

Greg holds a PhD in Behavioural Decision Theory from Cambridge; has held academic affiliations at UCL, Imperial College, and Oxford; and is author of Behavioral Investment Management.

Greg is also Chair of Sound and Music, the UK’s national charity for new music, and the creator of Open Outcry, a ‘reality opera’ premiered in London in 2012, creating live performance from a functioning trading floor.

Follow Greg B Davies on Twitter

We and our selected partners use cookies to enhance and personalise your experience on our website.Please see our cookie policy for more information.

To enhance your user experience on our site, learn more about our supported browsers

Your browser's cookies are disabled. Enable cookies to ensure our website functions correctly. View our Privacy Notice.