Site url: https://www.momentum.co.za/momentum/personal/investments/invest/offshore-investing/global-matters/weekly-digest/well-that-wasnt-expected
Pagecontext: org.apache.jasper.runtime.PageContextImpl@e56d81b4
NameValue
breadcrumb.start.level4
ibm.portal.instantiation.page.include.descendantsfalse
param.sharing.scope.{http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/prod/datatype/content}ibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
param.sharing.scope.{http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/prod/datatype/content/resource-collections}ibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
param.sharing.scope.{http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/prod/websphere/portal/v8.0/portal-contextual-portal}ibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
wcm.template.oidZ6_48GC1K80O0FH90QS83FHN530K6
flush.cache?01102021
param.sharing.scope.{http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/prod/websphere/portal/publicparams}path-infoibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
breadcrumb.enabledtrue
param.template.pageZ6_48GC1K80O0FH90QS83FHN530K6
page.keywordsOffshore investing
param.sharing.scope.{http://www.ibm.com/xmlns/prod/websphere/portal/v7.0/portal-contextual-portal}ibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
hide.from.menutrue
hide.childrentrue
breadcrumb.stop.level4
dynamic.sitemapfalse
param.sharing.scope.{http://ibm.connections.com/portlet}ibm.portal.sharing.scope.page
page.robotsall
label.namepersonal
sitecontext:personal
ibm.template.oidZ6_48GC1K80O0FH90QS83FHN530K6
menu.dividertrue
menu



Richard Parfect | 16 January 2023

Well, that wasn’t expected...

Share this article

Having booked my first skiing holiday in 11 years with some friends in Chamonix towards the end of January, I’m seeing news articles showing temperatures approaching 10c and zero snow on the ground. When I booked the trip for my group, of all the things I considered that might scupper the trip; no snow in the Alps, in January, was not one of them.

Investing is far from immune to such tales of the unexpected. At Momentum Global Investment Management (MGIM), one of the areas we focus on are specialist REITs, where we select asset managers to operate in specific areas of the property market that we feel offer the best opportunities for risk adjusted returns. When combined with tactical timing, we have found success with examples that include AEW UK REIT and LondonMetric. However, this does not come without risk.

Risk is integral to investing; it is ultimately what determines returns. Nevertheless, the actual risk sometimes diverges from the risk that would reasonably be expected from the strategy or asset type and it’s by monitoring this that active management on our part can add value.

A very recent example is our recently exited investment in Home REIT. We had been very supportive towards this REIT as it apparently ticked many boxes: inflation linked rental income supporting a progressive dividend; increasing the supply of accommodation for various types of homeless individuals and families; reducing the financial burden on local authorities that traditionally pay for expensive, poor quality, temporary B&B accommodation.

Despite these optical benefits and strong share price performance, we initially became concerned by personnel changes at the asset manager and poor disclosure of financial difficulties being faced by one of its tenant Community Interest Companies (CIC) “Circle Housing”. A few months back one of our team members, Gary Moglione, then performed some in-depth analysis of the various CIC and charitable tenants of the REIT.

It was an expansive project, but in summary, our concerns grew significantly when we discovered connections between different tenants that raised questions over effective diversification. The quality of the tenants failed to match our previous expectations. Finally, a meeting with the manager failed to satisfy any of our concerns. If anything, they were deepened.

The risks we were uncovering were far exceeding what we had initially anticipated for the asset type. The often quoted “government backing” as tenant of last resort felt inadequate for the risks that would be faced in any resolution process upon failure. Furthermore, with the general sell off that had occurred across various asset classes amidst the Gilt and government crisis of the Autumn, we felt there were better opportunities elsewhere. Our initial reductions were commenced at the start of November and as our concerns grew, we accelerated the program and finally exited on the 18 November when the shares were still trading around 75p.

We have watched with dismay (and significant relief) as subsequent to our exit there was a published “short report” by Viceroy Research LLC in the US1. This triggered a chain of events that saw the shares collapse to 38p, the publication of the annual results has been delayed, and the shares suspended from the market. While we cannot pre-empt the investigation by the auditor, this could be a sad example of a failure of public markets to achieve a stated financial and social objective. It is also a reminder to us that the greatest risks sometimes lurk in the least expected places. Furthermore, it shows that it is not just skiers that take a gradual climb followed by a steep descent; assuming there’s some snow around.

Source: 1Home REIT - No place like Home REIT… thankfully | Viceroy Research, Home REIT Regulatory News

Share this article

In case you missed it

09 JANUARY 2023

Divine inspiration

Alex Harvey, CFA

This year presents us with a fuller palette of investment opportunities than we’ve seen for some years.


12 DECEMBER 2022

What were you thinking?

Tom Delic

A valuation discipline is designed to place the odds in your favour.



5 DECEMBER 2022

A turning point for UK mid-caps

Mark Wright, CFA

Fearful investors heading for the exit have crushed valuations this year by driving down share prices.


We and our selected partners use cookies to enhance and personalise your experience on our website.Please see our cookie policy for more information.

To enhance your user experience on our site, learn more about our supported browsers

Your browser's cookies are disabled. Enable cookies to ensure our website functions correctly. View our Privacy Notice.

Tell us more!

We're always looking for ways to improve your online experience. Please take a moment to complete the
2-minute questionnaire.